If you prefer to view the website always in english, click here.

{{content.phone.title}}

{{content.phone.text}}

{{content.phone.phoneText}}

{{content.form.title}}

{{content.form.text}}

{{content.form.errors.server}}

{{content.form.success.title}}

{{content.form.success.message}} {{model.phone}}

{{content.cta.title}}

{{content.cta.text}}

{{content.app.title}}

{{content.app.text}}

Butane cylinder or natural gas: which is better for your home?

If you don't use much gas, butane cylinders can save you some of the standing charges associated with natural gas, even though bottled gas is more expensive per cubic metre. However, if you use gas every day in your primary residence, a mains piped supply is much more convenient for combining hot water, cooking and, above all, central heating. Knowing which gas to choose is straightforward. All you need to do is compare your needs, consumption habits and overall costs, including installation, energy efficiency and standing charges. 

What is the difference between butane and natural gas?

Both butane and natural gas are fossil fuels, but they differ in almost every other respect: where they come from, how they reach your home, how much heat they generate and, in certain conditions, how they perform in extreme temperatures.

Two gases with different compositions and physical states

Natural gas consists almost entirely of methane. It is extracted from underground reserves similar to crude oil fields, liquefied for international transport, and regasified for piped distribution to homes across a mains network.

Butane, on the other hand, is a petroleum derivative. It is extracted during the refining process, liquefied for storage and distribution in gas bottles or cylinders, and vaporises back into gas when released from the cylinder during use.

How natural gas and butane reach your home

Natural gas is delivered through pipelines to your home, ensuring a continuous supply with no need for storage.

Butane, meanwhile, requires purchasing and replacing cylinders. This requires storage space at home and manual handling to connect the bottles to your water heater and hob.

Calorific value also differs between the two gases

Butane has a higher calorific value than natural gas (26.2 kWh/Nm³ compared with 10.8 kWh/Nm³), meaning it generates more heat per unit of volume. Consequently, you need less butane than natural gas to achieve a similar heating output.

Natural gas performs better in cold climates

Natural gas can withstand temperatures down to -5 °C, whereas butane loses pressure below 0 °C. This is an important factor to consider if your home is located in a very cold climate, as you will need to keep a closer eye on the cylinder and protect it from freezing temperatures.

 

How much does a shower cost with butane gas vs natural gas?

In practice, butane's higher calorific value is offset by natural gas's lower cost per kWh. That is why it is important to compare both options in real-world everyday use. For a 10-minute shower, for example – assuming identical water temperature, boiler performance and system efficiency – here is an indicative comparison of the energy cost between the two fuels:

Gas type:
Shower duration:
kWh used:
Cubic metres required:
Price per m3 of gas: Cost of the shower:
Butane*
10 minutes
2 kWh
0,062 m3
3,80 €/m3 €0.24
Natural gas*
10 minutes
2 kWh
0,172 m3
0,99 €/m3 €0.17

* Calculation based on the price of Endesa's Conecta Gas natural gas tariff (€0.0845/kWh, equivalent to €0.99/m3) and the price of a 12.5 kg butane cylinder (€18.84, equivalent to €3.80/m3), as of 13 October 2026. 

 

Butane cylinders or natural gas for home heating

The difference between a quick 10-minute shower and running central heating all day paints a clear picture: getting through the winter on butane cylinders can be significantly more expensive than heating your home with mains natural gas.

On top of the financial aspect, piped gas provides the convenience of an uninterrupted supply, eliminating the hassle of constantly replacing heavy butane bottles.

However, having a choice is not always possible. According to data from the Spanish Gas Association (SEDIGAS), only 31% of homes have access to piped natural gas. And while the more than 1,800 connected municipalities account for the vast majority of the population, butane cylinders remain commonplace in rural or remote areas, milder regions and second homes.

In these areas, pairing butane with electric heating and cooling systems or other energy sources, alongside portable gas heaters to warm individual rooms, provides viable money-saving alternatives where piped gas is unavailable.

 

The real costs of natural gas and butane

To get a full, fair comparison between both energy sources, you need to look beyond unit rates and factor in additional costs that can be decisive.

With butane cylinders, for instance, you must factor in the initial service connection fee, which is mandatory and ranges from €10 to €40 depending on the supplier. You also have to pay a deposit on the first cylinder you purchase. This deposit can vary substantially, from just €3 to over €18, depending on the cylinder model and whether you set up a direct debit contract.

Natural gas, meanwhile, requires an upfront outlay to connect the property to the distribution network if it does not already have a service connection. This represents a relatively significant investment, so it is worth weighing up whether long-term energy savings will offset the cost over time. In addition, mains gas involves recurring monthly charges: the standing charge paid simply for connection to the supply, along with regulated system charges and government-set taxes.

 

How much does a butane cylinder cost in 2026?

A standard 12.5 kg butane cylinder costs €18.84 on the regulated market in October 2026.

This is the official price set on 15 September, which remains in force until its bi-monthly review in mid-November. However, beyond guaranteeing this traditional cylinder at the regulated price, suppliers are free to offer different cylinder formats at market rates. These unregulated prices vary according to product volume, materials and cylinder design.

 

How much does natural gas cost with Endesa?

The consumption price for natural gas with Endesa is €0.0845/kWh under the Conecta Gas tariff for new customers, as of 13 October 2026.

Natural gas also has a regulated market: the Last Resort Tariff (TUR). In this market, prices are reviewed quarterly by the government. Given this price volatility, fixed-rate deals on the free market can often prove more attractive when gas prices follow an upward trend.

 

Do you have to pay to switch gas types at home?

Switching from natural gas to bottled butane, or vice versa, requires converting your boiler and household appliances to the new fuel. This applies in both directions because the two gases operate at different pressures and densities. The overall cost depends on appliance compatibility and your property's existing infrastructure.

  • If your appliances are dual-fuel compatible and the home has a natural gas connection, a visit from a qualified technician to change the burner nozzles is usually all that is required.
  • However, if you need to replace your boiler or hob, or carry out building works to bring piped gas into the property, the costs will be considerably higher.

 

€/kg for cylinders vs €/kWh for natural gas: comparing like with like

At first glance, comparing the price of piped natural gas with bottled butane is not straightforward. Mainly because natural gas is billed in €/kWh, whereas butane is simply sold at a fixed price per bottle.

The easiest way to compare them is to convert both options into common units, such as cubic metres. In fact, domestic gas meters measure consumption in cubic metres before energy suppliers convert that volume into €/kWh on your bill, as required by law.

A standard 12.5 kg butane cylinder expands to roughly 5 m3 of gas during use. This allows you to compare equivalent units – namely the cost in euros per cubic metre (€/m3) – while always remembering that butane yields roughly twice as much heat energy as natural gas.

 

Key considerations when choosing between butane and natural gas 

Either butane or natural gas could be the right choice for your home. Beyond unit pricing and network availability, here are several key criteria to weigh up before deciding:

  1. Cumulative long-term savings: rather than focusing solely on current rates, calculate which fuel will be more economical for your household year after year.
  2. Convenience: while scheduled cylinder deliveries are available, running out of gas and making emergency trips to buy a replacement bottle is common during periods of higher consumption. With piped natural gas, you never have to check fuel levels or worry about ordering refills.
  3. Storage space: while natural gas enters directly from the mains network, butane cylinders take up space at home – and twice as much if you keep a spare bottle on hand. 
  4. Installation costs: if your home is not connected to the mains network, paying for a gas network connection can require a sizeable capital outlay, which is completely avoided with bottled gas.
  5. Safety: while mandatory statutory inspections are required for both systems to ensure home safety, bottled gas requires closer monitoring during transport, storage and routine bottle replacement.
  6. Environmental impact: both fuels are fossil hydrocarbons, but natural gas burns more consistently and cleanly, resulting in lower atmospheric pollutant emissions.

 

When is a butane cylinder the better option?

Generally speaking, if your home has low gas consumption, bottled butane is often the most economical choice. In second homes, for example, cylinders provide energy on demand without incurring fixed standing charges throughout the year. 

The same applies to properties with minimal heating requirements and small households with modest cooking and hot water usage.

The third reason to choose butane is network availability. In rural properties or low-density areas situated away from mains gas pipelines, butane remains the go-to fuel, often paired with electricity.

 

When is natural gas more convenient?

The arguments in favour of natural gas almost all relate to scale. Large families with heavy hot water demand and frequent use of a gas hob. Large houses that require substantial central heating. And, of course, towns and cities large enough to feature an established gas distribution network.

In these scenarios, high and steady consumption ensures that the upfront installation and fixed standing charges of natural gas are quickly recouped through lower unit rates.

 

The formula to calculate what you would pay with butane vs natural gas

Having looked at reasons, pricing and the need to compare like-for-like units when assessing the real cost, here is a formula to help work out whether it makes sense to switch fuels at home:

If you currently have a natural gas contract, run this calculation

First, add up your total spending on gas consumption and monthly standing charge over the past year.

As a benchmark, according to the Institute for Energy Diversification and Saving (IDAE), average annual domestic natural gas consumption in Spain is approximately 435 m3 (5,100 kWh). Based on Endesa's Conecta Gas tariff rates, this equates to roughly €517 per year (€0.0845/kWh for energy consumed plus a €7.181/month standing charge).

Given that butane has double the calorific value of natural gas, you would have needed half the volume over the course of the year: 217.5 m3. That equates to the gas content of 43.5 standard 12.5 kg cylinders. At the current regulated price per cylinder, that annual usage would have cost you around €820 with butane.

If you have low consumption and use butane, run the reverse calculation

Suppose your second home uses only a fifth of the energy consumed by an average household over the course of a year. That equates to 8.7 butane cylinders per year (one-fifth of 43.5), giving an annual cost of €163.91.

If you were to calculate this using natural gas, the cost of the energy consumed would have been one-fifth: €86.19. However, to that lower consumption cost you must add the monthly standing charge, payable even during months when no gas is used: another €86 over the entire year. Consequently, natural gas in that second home would cost you €172.19 per year.

 

Endesa natural gas tariffs

As shown above, natural gas is often the most economical choice depending on your circumstances. If you decide to go with piped gas, the next step is choosing a tariff tailored to your consumption and needs. Because every household has different ways to maximise savings.

With Endesa, for instance, you can enjoy price stability with fixed-rate natural gas tariffs or, for added peace of mind, pair your energy plan with technical services and payment protection through solutions like Comprehensive Gas Maintenance or Protección Gas 360.

You can also make switching from butane to natural gas easier with new boiler installation packages, preferential rates and reward points via Endesa PARA TI.

And to manage all your home utilities in one place, you can bundle electricity and gas together to unlock even greater benefits.

 

Frequently asked questions about butane and natural gas

Is natural gas cheaper than bottled butane?

Natural gas is cheaper per unit of energy (€/kWh). However, for very low or intermittent consumption, butane cylinders can work out cheaper overall, as natural gas incurs a fixed monthly standing charge regardless of whether any gas is used.

Is natural gas better than butane for cooking?

Both gases deliver comparable cooking performance, although butane is marginally more efficient due to its higher calorific value. In fact, many gas hobs can easily be adapted to run on either fuel simply by replacing the burner nozzles.

Do you save more by using natural gas for hot water?

It depends on how much hot water your household uses. Natural gas delivers noticeable savings for regular daily use, whereas bottled butane can prove more cost-effective for occasional or seasonal demand.

Is home heating more expensive with butane cylinders than with natural gas?

For whole-house central heating, yes. Butane cylinders are suitable for small heating appliances, such as portable heaters. However, the high energy demand required to heat an entire home makes piped natural gas far more economical.

How much does a butane cylinder cost?

€18.84 is the official regulated price for a standard 12.5 kg cylinder as of October 2026. However, on the free market you will find a broad spectrum of prices depending on the supplier, gas volume, cylinder materials and other factors.

How often does the price of a butane cylinder change?

The regulated price for a standard 12.5 kg cylinder is reviewed every two months. On the unregulated free market, prices can change at the supplier's discretion.

Do I have to pay for natural gas even if I don't use any?

In part, yes. You pay a small fixed monthly standing charge even if zero gas is consumed during the billing period. This charge covers the cost of maintaining the distribution infrastructure that delivers piped gas directly to your property.

Does butane perform poorly in freezing weather?

It can do if the cylinder is not properly protected. Butane begins to freeze around 0 °C, so it is advisable to shelter cylinders from extreme cold to ensure steady gas pressure.

Do butane cylinders require more safety precautions than natural gas?

Yes, particularly because cylinders must be manually handled and reconnected every time a bottle runs out, in addition to safety requirements governing transport and storage.

When is it worth switching to natural gas?

Whenever your consumption is relatively high and consistent throughout the year. This allows the lower unit rates to offset the fixed standing charge and any upfront installation costs over time.

What can I do if mains natural gas is not available in my area?

First, check with your local gas distributor to see if the mains pipeline can be extended to your property from the nearest connection point. If that is not viable, you can combine alternative energy solutions such as electricity, bottled butane and other options.

Comparison of Electricity and Gas Tariffs

You don't need to adapt to Endesa's tariffs because they adapt to you. If you go to our catalogue you can compare the different tariffs for yourself. Or if you prefer, you can answer a few questions and we will take care of comparing all the different electricity and gas tariffs and then make a customised recommendation.

Do you want to see all our offers?

Spend a minute to find the product which best adapts to you:

Discover the rate that best suits your consumption profile with our smart recommender

We are finding the right energy for you...